Best Toilet Seat Reviews & Buying Guide

The toilet is one of the most important accessories in a home. A house that doesn’t have a toilet is incomplete and completely unliveable. Also, toilets need to be clean and hygienic. Toilet seats help keep our bathrooms sanitary and enhance comfort when answering the call of nature. If you’re shopping for the best toilet seat, you’ll be glad to learn that they come in a wide variety of colors, shapes, styles, and materials. But since online shopping spaces are brimming with different models and brands, choosing the right toilet seat for your bathroom can be a challenge.

If your toilet did not come with a toilet seat or your current lid is not working properly, you’ll need a new seat. Let’s face it, most people will only appreciate the importance of a toilet seat when their current lid is not holding the weight. Once cracks start to show or hinges start to come off, you know you need a new toilet seat. Whether it’s a composting toilet, an upflush toilet, or a portable potty for camping, a toilet seat makes all the difference in their comfort and sanitation. In this guide, you will find comprehensive reviews of the best toilet seats on the market plus a detailed buying guide to make your purchase decision easier. Read on!

Top Ten Best Toilet Seats

There are hundreds of toilet seats to choose from and having to choose one from the myriads of options available is not easy. Today’s toilets seats offer more options than ever before thanks to advancements in technology further complicating the process of choosing the right toilet seat for your bathroom. Here’s a list of our top ten best toilet seats in the market along with an in-depth review of each to help you out.

Quick-Comparison

BrandProduct NameEditor's PickPriceRating
BATH ROYALE BR620-00 Premium Round Toilet SeatBest Overall$$$4.7
Kohler K-4636-96 Cachet Elongated Toilet SeatBest Runner-Up$$$4.4
KOHLER K-4694-0 Ridgewood Toilet SeatBest Universal Seat$$4.3
Toto SS114#01 Transitional SoftClose Toilet SeatBest Soft-Close Design$$$$4.3
AquaSense Portable Elevated Toilet SeatBest Budget Pick$4.3
*Ratings courtesy of Amazon at the time of publication and can change!

#1: Best Overall: BATH ROYALE BR620-00 Premium Round Toilet Seat

Our top pick for the best toilet seats is the BATH ROYALE BR620-00 Premium Round Toilet Seat.  This toilet seat features a sturdy, 100% pure polypropylene construction that is non-absorbent and chemical- and stain-resistant. The BR620-00 Premium toilet seat comes with a built-in slow-close function, which goes a long way when it comes to preventing loud slamming, pinched fingers, and cracked toilet bowls. BATH ROYALE’S soft-close function is unique as it allows forced closing without damaging the hinges. You can easily push the seat closed when it’s closing too slow. Thanks to the seat’s quick release feature, you can detach the seat with the touch of a button for cleaning or replacement purposes.

What we like
  • Strong build. The toilet seat is made from pure polypropylene, making it highly durable.
  • Easy to install. It provides for straightforward installation, and all mounting accessories come with the seat, including mounting bases and stainless-steel screws.
What we don’t like
  • Round toilets only but fits most toilet brands, including Kohler, American Standard, Crane, and Toto.
  • Installation. Some users experienced difficulty when trying to install the toilet seat

#2: Best Runner-Up: Kohler K-4636-96 Cachet Elongated Toilet Seat

The Kohler K-4636-96 Cachet Biscuit Toilet Seat is one of the best toilet seats you can purchase at the moment. The quiet close function is one of the best features this toilet seat offers. It allows the toilet seat to close slowly without slamming or any other type of disturbance with just a slight touch. The Kohler K-4636-96 Cachet Elongated Biscuit Toilet Seat is made from frozen polypropylene, which makes it highly resistant to a wide variety of degrading factors, including chipping, fade, and stains. The toilet seat is designed to fit any elongated toilet seat, and it doesn’t have to be Kohler.

What we like
  • No shifting. The toilet seat comes with separately installed unique grip tight bumpers that effectively hold the rim in place to prevent shifting.
  • Easy to clean. Features quick-release technology which makes it easy to remove the seat for cleaning or replacement purposes.
  • 12 months guarantee. The product is backed by a 12-month guarantee, which assures buyers of the quality of the product they are purchasing.
What we don’t like
  • Weak build. It is not strong enough, and some users have reported breakage after a few weeks of use.

#3: Best Universal Pick: KOHLER K-4694-0 Ridgewood Toilet Seat

The KOHLER K-4694-0 Ridgewood Toilet Seat is ergonomically designed for superior comfort. This wooden toilet seat offers great design, durability, and finish that will match the shape, size, and color of most toilets out there. Compared to traditional plastic toilet seats, the KOHLER K-4694-0 Ridgewood Toilet Seat comes with a heavy and solid build and will last longer. The toilet seat is made from compression-molded wood and is designed to fit one-piece or two-piece elongated toilets. This toilet seat can fit just about any toilet out there. The compression-molded wood construction creates a look and a feel that’s impossible to achieve with materials such as plastic.  

What we like
  • Universal. The KOHLER K-4694-0 Ridgewood Toilet Seat will fit any toilet you have in your house, one-piece or two-piece, as long as you have the measurements right.
  • Built to last. The KOHLER K-4694-0 Ridgewood Toilet Seat comes in a solid compression-molded wood that is durable and does not compromise on comfort.
  • Easy installation. The toilet seat features a plastic rim which makes it extremely easy to install with just a screwdriver.
What we don’t like
  • Staining. Some customers who bought this product have raised staining complaints. Apparently, there were stains after a few weeks of use even with regular cleaning.

#4: Best Soft-close Design: Toto SS114#01 Transitional SoftClose Toilet Seat

The Toto SS114#01 Transitional SoftClose Toilet Seat features a high quality, high-impact gloss polypropylene construction and rubber pads to improve stability. The toilet is built to last, and the seamless look created by the seat’s slim and sleek design will give your bathroom a classy, modern appearance. The Toto SS114#01 features SoftClose Technology that allows the seat and the lid to close gently and silently thus eliminating slamming. The Toto SS114#01 Transitional SoftClose Toilet Seat is extremely easy to install and is available in a variety of assorted colors – you can choose one that blends with your bathroom décor.

What we like
  • Ease of installation. The toilet seat is easy to install and adjust and comes with necessary mounting and installation hardware.
  • SoftClose Technology. The built-in slow-closing hinge system allows the seat and lid to close quietly and gently thus eliminating slamming.
  • Durable. The Toto SS114#01 is constructed with solid high-impact, high gloss polypropylene, a top-notch material that is highly durable.
What we don’t like
  • Inward dent. The toilet seat comes with an inward dent instead of an outside one, which can be a problem for some users.

#5: Best Budget Pick: AquaSense Portable Elevated Toilet Seat

The AquaSense Portable Toilet Seat comes with a unique feature that allows it to stand out from the rest of the products in our best toilet seats list. As the name suggests, this exceptional toilet seat raises the toilet four inches higher than a standard toilet seat. The ergonomic design allows users to get on and off the seat easily. The sturdy polyethylene construction features a seamless design that’s extremely easy to clean. The bad news is that the AquaSense Portable Raised Toilet Seat will not fit your elongated toilet as it is designed for standard commode bowls.

What we like
  • Raised toilet seat. Elevated toilet seat which makes it easy to get on and off the toilet. Ideal for people with limited mobility.
  • Lightweight. The seat is extremely lightweight, which makes you can easily move around or travel with it.
  • Durable. Made from high-quality polyethylene material that is strong and designed to last longer than other common materials.
  • Safety. The seat is designed to help people with limited mobility to use the toilet safely and confidently without assistance or pain.
What we don’t like
  • The toilet seat does not fit on elongated toilets

#6: Best Wood Design: MAYFAIR Natural Oak Veneer Toilet Seat

The MAYFAIR Natural Oak Veneer Toilet Seat is one of the best toilet seats in the market at the moment. The toilet seat comes in a striking design that features classic chrome hinges and a wood finish that brings natural beauty to your bathroom. The MAYFAIR Natural Oak Veneer Toilet Seat is made from natural oak, so don’t expect any cracking or splitting. The toilet is made to last for decades and is extremely easy to install. This toilet seat is designed for round toilets from all manufacturers in Canada and the United States, including Kohler, American Standard, TOTO, and many more.

What we like
  • Durable. The toilet seat is made from natural oak and veneer, which makes it highly durable.
  • Great finish. The toilet comes with a very neat finish. It’s available in a variety of shades and you can easily choose one that complements your bathroom décor.
  • Easy to install. The toilet seat is easy to install as a DIY and is designed to fit all round toilets regardless of the manufacturer.
What we don’t like
  • Sliding. Some users raised sliding as one of the major issues with the MAYFAIR Natural Oak Veneer toilet seat.

#7: Best Sturdy Build: MAYFAIR 1848SLOW 006

As one of the best toilet seats in the market, the MAYFAIR 1848SLOW 006 comes in an elegant design and a load of interesting features. For instance, the toilet seat comes with Whisper Close technology which makes it very difficult to hear the toilet seat closing even from inside the bathroom. You can’t hear a thing from the other side of the bathroom door as the toilet slowly closes after use. If you are easily bothered by slamming toilet seats, the MAYFAIR 1848SLOW 006 is the perfect toilet seat for you. This toilet seat also features the STA-TITE Seat Fastening System, allowing the seat to attach firmly to the toilet and stay that way.

What we like
  • Easy to clean. The toilet features an Easy Clean & Change feature that allows for easy removal for cleaning and replacement.
  • Seat Fastening System. The STA-TITE Seat Fastening System holds the toilet seat firmly to the bowl. This means that the seat will not shift around or slide.
  • Sturdy build. The toilet seat comes in a solid molded wood construction with a high gloss finish that prevents scratching and chipping.
What we don’t like
  • Installation problems. Some customers who purchased this product reported a bit of difficulty when trying to install the toilet seat the first time.

#8: Best for Durability: BEMIS 1500EC 000 Toilet Seat

If you are looking for a simple, highly functional, and durable toilet seat, you might want to check out the BEMIS 1500EC 000 Toilet Seat. This is also one of the most budget-friendly options in the market. So, it’s a great pick if you want a high-quality product without having to dig too deep in your pocket. The BEMIS 1500EC 000 Toilet Seat features a solid molded wood construction with a glossy finish, which makes it resistant to chipping. Once installed, the toilet seat is very comfortable and secure. It’s firmly attached to the bowl to prevent shifting. The seat is heavy-duty and is manufactured in the USA.

What we like
  • Durable. The seat comes in a heavy and solid molded wood construction with a glossy finish that’s resistant to chipping.
  • Easy Installation. Installation only takes a few minutes with a screwdriver or a quarter. Once installed, the toilet seat is securely attached to the bowl and does not slide around.
  • Easy to clean. All you need to do is twist the hinges to remove the toilet seat and clean areas that are hard to reach.
What we don’t like
  • Longevity issues. Some buyers reported breakage after a few weeks of using the toilet seat, which could be a case of faulty manufacturing.

#9: Best for Slow-close: American Standard 5325.010.020 Champion Toilet Seat

Thanks to a unique material called duroplast that’s made to bear a striking resemblance to china, the American Standard 5325.010.020 Champion Toilet Seat is one of the few toilet seats in the market that are actually built to last. The toilet seat comes with easy lift-off hinges that allow the user to remove and attach the toilet seat for cleaning without using any tools. This toilet seat also features a Slow-Close Function that allows the user to close the toilet seat slowly and quietly with a soft nudge. The American Standard 5325.010.020 Champion Toilet Seat blends in with a variety of bathroom décors.

What we like
  • Easy installation. The toilet seat comes with necessary installation hardware and only takes a few minutes to install.
  • Slow Close Function. This feature allows the toilet to close slowly and quietly without slamming.
  • Easy lift-off hinges. The toilet seat is extremely easy to remove and attach without using any tools, which makes it easy to clean.
What we don’t like
  • Gravity hinge wearing out. Some buyers have raised the issue of gravity hinge breaking or wearing out thus disabling the slow close function.

#10: Best for Commercial Toilets: BEMIS 7800TDG 000 Commercial Heavy-Duty Toilet Seat

If you are looking for a heavy-duty commercial toilet seat that will last for decades, look no further than the BEMIS 7800TDG 000 Commercial Heavy-Duty Toilet Seat. This closed front toilet seat is made from an injection of molded solid plastic and comes with a sturdy build, strong enough to support a small army without bulging an inch. The toilet seat is plain and simple, nothing gimmicky about the quick release hinges or its slow close design. The BEMIS 7800TDG 000 Commercial Heavy-Duty Toilet Seat is purely functional, nothing fancy about it. Most importantly, unlike other toilet seats in the market, this product is built to last.

What we like
  • Easy installation. The seat comes ready to install and will fit into any elongated toilet without hassle.
  • Durable. This heavy-duty toilet seat is built to last and features a high-quality plastic build and non-corrosive 300 Series stainless-steel posts hinge.
  • Commercial Fastening System. The toilet seat comes with a STA-TITE commercial fastening system that will never get loose.
What we don’t like
  • No soft-close. The toilet seat lacks soft-close technology, which can be a major turn off for a lot of buyers.

There you go, ladies and gentlemen! That’s our list of the top ten toilet seats available on the market at the moment. You can purchase any of these toilet seats in your nearest store or order online from Amazon, which is the easier option in today’s tech-driven world. Most of the products on our list are available in round and elongated options and will more likely make a perfect fit for your toilet bowl. All you need to do is make sure that you have the measurements right before you make an order.

Best Toilet Seat Brands

BEMIS 7800TDG 000 Commercial Heavy-Duty Toilet Seat.

Founded in 1901, Bemis Manufacturing Company is the world’s largest manufacturer of toilet seats. The company strives to continuously improve its products to give customers what they need. The BEMIS 7800TDG 000 Commercial Heavy-Duty Toilet Seat is no different. Made with earth-friendly materials and processes right here in the USA, this product features a Commercial Fastening System and will fit all elongated toilets, including Kohler, American Standard, TOTO, and many more.

Kohler K-4636-96 Cachet Elongated Biscuit Toilet Seat.

Kohler is an American manufacturing company based in Kohler, Wisconsin. Founded in 1873, the company is best known for manufacturing high-quality plumbing products. In line with the company’s manufacturing model, the Kohler K-4636-96 Cachet Elongated Biscuit Toilet Seat combines subtle styling and innovative technology. The quiet close technology ensures that the toilet seat doesn’t slam when closing. There’s no shifting, thanks to the Unique Grip Tight bumpers which makes the K-4636-96 one of the best toilet seats in the market.

BATH ROYALE BR620-00 Premium Round Toilet Seat.

Based in Davidson, NC, Bath Royale is a small, family-owned business that specializes in the design and production of luxury bathroom accessories. The company strives to provide stylish, yet highly-functional, best-in-class products and the BATH ROYALE BR620-00 Premium Round Toilet Seat is enough testimony. The BR620-00 Premium Round Toilet Seat offers unique features, superior performance, and quality, which is why it earned the top spot our list of the best toilet seats.

The Best Toilet Seat Buying Guide

With countless options available on the market, choosing the right toilet seat can be a nightmare. There are so many possibilities and considerations, for instance, the material, model, etc. Should you buy a plastic or a wooden toilet seat? Other important factors to consider when shopping for a toilet seat are the size, shape, color, comfort, design, and other key features. Below, we’ve outlined the criteria for choosing the best toilet seat for your bathroom.

Size

Size is one of the most important factors when it comes to choosing a toilet seat. These products are available in a range of sizes, and you need to make sure that you get the correct size that fits your toilet bowl perfectly. All you need to do is take measurements before you purchase a toilet seat. Measure the length of your toilet from the back to the farthest part of the front. Also, measure the width and the distance between hinges to get the most accurate measurements.

Shape

Another key consideration to make when buying a toilet seat is the shape. The two most common toilet shapes are round and elongated. Do you have a round or an elongated-shaped toilet? The latter is more popular with modern plumbing fixtures while the former is commonly found in older homes. Knowing the shape of your toilet will help you choose a toilet seat that fits. Measuring the current seat from the hinge bolt to the front will give you a good indication of whether its round or elongated.

Material

Material is another important factor to consider when shopping for a toilet seat. Typically, toilet seats are made of plastic or wood. Each one of these materials comes with a unique set of advantages and disadvantages. Wooden toilet seats tend to be more sturdy and heavier. Toilet seats made of wood also add a touch of luxury to your bathroom. Plastic toilet seats, on the other hand, are lighter and last longer compared to their wooden counterparts.

Durability

If you don’t want to keep buying replacement toilet seats every now and then, the durability of your purchase is essential. The material used to make the toilet seat significantly affects its durability. As stated above, plastic toilet seats are more durable than wooden toilet seats. But keep in mind that different types of plastic have varying lifespans. Also, consider the maximum weight capacity of a toilet seat as it can affect its durability.

Ease of Installation

Consider the ease of installation when purchasing a toilet seat. A good toilet seat is simple and convenient. Sophisticated toilet seats are difficult to install and use, and may not even be worth your time. A well-built toilet seat should be easy to install. Make sure that the toilet seat comes with all the necessary installation hardware, including nuts and bolts you need to mount the seat on your toilet bowl.

Comfort

Considering the amount of time we spend sitting on a toilet seat, comfort is an essential factor when it comes to choosing a toilet seat. After all, that’s what toilet seats are made for. The material used to make the toilet seat has an impact on its comfort level. Wooden toilet seats, for instance, are warmer and more comfortable at first touch. However, some toilet seats (both wooden and plastic) come with padded seats for added comfort and warmth.

Color

Consider the color of the toilet seat and its impact on the appearance of your bathroom when choosing a toilet seat. The color of your toilet seat sets the mood in your bathroom. These products are available in a wide range of colors, so be sure to choose a color that blends with the rest of your bathroom décor, such as your bathroom vanity. A wooden toilet seat will give your bathroom an elegant sleek look while plastic toilet seats are more versatile in terms of available colors.

Additional Features

As stated earlier, modern toilet seats come with numerous additional features, thanks to advancements in technology. Today, you can choose a toilet seat with specific add-ons to accommodate individual needs. Most of these features are a matter of personal preference and it’s up to you to decide what you need. They include:

  • Soft Close. If it bothers you when a toilet seat makes a loud noise as it slams shut, then you need to consider one with a built-in soft-close mechanism. These toilet seats come with specially designed hinges that allow the toilet seat to shut slowly and quietly without slamming.
  • Secure Fit. Some toilet seats come with a rubber bumper below the plastic rim for a stronger grip onto the toilet bowl, which eliminates sliding and slipping. This feature is known as Secure Fit.
  • Quick Installation. Some toilet seats come with a quick installation feature which is basically a set of seat bumpers that allow quick and easy installation.
  • Quick Release. The quick-release feature allows for faster removal of the toilet seat from the toilet bowl for easier cleaning. Removing the seat from the bowl doesn’t require any tools.

Other additional features you may want to consider when shopping for the best toilet seat include Lighted Toilet Seat (adds a nightlight component for easier use in the dark), Deodorizer (adds a carbon filter to the rim/bidet to remove bad odors, which can be a great feature for large households), and Cleansing Toilet Seat (an alternative to standard toilet paper that cleans your backside by shooting pressurized water).

Best Toilet Seats: FAQs

What should I look for when buying a toilet seat?

There are hundreds of toilet seats in the market, so you need to look at certain factors when shopping to make sure that you get the right one. These include ease of installation, cost, slow and quiet close feature, shape, and comfort.

Are toilet seats safe?

Toilets seats are safe as long as they are clean and hygienic. There are dozens of infections that you can get from a toilet seat if you don’t clean it properly.  Some of the disease-causing agents that may find home in a dirty toilet seat include E. Coli, Shigella bacteria, streptococcus, and staphylococcus.

Should I leave the toilet seat up or down?

It’s always good practice to ensure that you leave the toilet seat down when you are not using the toilet. Close the seat when you are done using the toilet and flashed it down. Flushing the toilet with the seat down is unhygienic.

Do all toilet seats stain?

Staining is a common occurrence in toilet seats. Any toilet seat is bound to get stained if it’s not cleaned properly and regularly. However, be careful with the products you use to clean your toilet seat as some are too harsh and may actually contribute to staining or bleaching.

How do I know if the seat will fit my toilet?

When buying a toilet seat, you need to make sure that you get the correct size. You don’t want to buy a seat that’s too small or too large for your toilet. Measure the distance from the back to the front (farthest point) as well as the width and the space between hinges for a perfect fit.

Best Toilet Seat: Wrap Up

We spend a lot of time sitting in our toilets. It’s not unusual for someone to bring their smartphone or a magazine to keep themselves busy when going about their business in the bathroom. Getting a toilet seat is one of the best ways to make your time in the bathroom as comfortable as possible. Our top pick for the best toilet seat, the BATH ROYALE BR620-00 Premium Round Toilet Seat, is simple, convenient, and comfortable. We hope this review guide will help you choose the best toilet seat that adds value to your bathroom without much hassle.


Leave a Comment